Why Company Values Often Sound the Same
Let's be honest: Could you associate the words appreciation, trust, respect, and sustainability with a specific company?
Probably not. Browse through the mission statements of different organizations, and you will encounter the same terms again and again. They sound positive, but they are often interchangeable.
Why is that? Do companies lack creativity or individuality?
One explanation comes from linguistics. The concept of high-value words describes terms that carry particularly positive associations and naturally generate widespread approval.
Love, freedom, justice, and respect are typical examples. Hardly anyone would disagree with these values. After all, have you ever heard someone say, "Working in a respectful environment? Absolutely not!"
The problem isn't the company values themselves. The problem is that they reveal very little about how an organization actually operates.
Because a value everyone agrees with is not necessarily a value everyone lives by.
Corporate Culture Isn't Created on Paper
In my work with companies and leaders, I regularly see how much time and energy organizations invest in defining their core values.
There are discussions, priorities are established, and individual words are carefully selected. Eventually, four or five values appear on the company website, in presentations, or on posters.
But that's when the real work begins. And all too often, that work never happens.
Employees don't experience corporate culture through carefully crafted statements. They experience it through everyday interactions.
How does a manager react when someone makes a mistake? What happens when an employee unexpectedly needs time off to care for a sick child? Is an uncomfortable opinion genuinely heard or quietly ignored?
These are the moments that reveal what a company truly stands for.
What Stories Do People Tell About Your Company?
That's why, when working on corporate culture, I like to ask a question that often surprises people:
"What stories do people tell about your company?"
Not: What values are written in your mission statement?
Instead: What experiences have inspired, disappointed, or deeply influenced the people working there?
Perhaps it's the story of a manager who stood up for their team during a difficult situation. Or a colleague who received extraordinary support during a personal crisis.
Or perhaps it's a story about a decision where financial interests were prioritized over employee well-being.
Only then do I ask: Which value does this story represent?
Suddenly, the abstract concept of "trust" becomes a real experience. "Appreciation" becomes visible behavior. And "responsibility" becomes a decision people remember for years.
Start With the Story, Not the Value
This is where I believe the most important shift in perspective begins.
Companies don't always need to define their values first and then try to convince employees to embrace them.
A far more powerful approach is to discover which values are already being practiced and which stories bring them to life.
This makes corporate culture tangible. It creates identification and belonging while revealing where the organization's aspirations and everyday reality may differ.
Because a credible employer brand isn't built through the right words.
It's built through meaningful experiences that create a lasting emotional connection.
Conclusion: Living Your Company Values Matters More Than Any Mission Statement
Here's my suggestion for your next leadership meeting:
Don't start by asking: "What values do we stand for?"
Instead, ask: "Which story from our company best illustrates who we really are?"
The answer will often tell you more than any mission statement ever could.
About the Author – Dr. Susanne Dietz
Dr. Susanne Dietz is an expert in future-ready corporate culture, modern leadership, and work-life integration. As a keynote speaker, trainer, coach, and consultant, she helps organizations create working environments where trust, appreciation, and responsibility are not just written down but genuinely practiced.
Through her inspiring keynotes and practical workshops, she demonstrates how leaders and teams can build a more human-centered, authentic, and sustainable corporate culture.
Would you like to bring your company values to life and strengthen your leadership culture for the future?
Invite Dr. Susanne Dietz to inspire your team at your next corporate event, leadership conference, or company workshop.
Discover Dr. Susanne Dietz on Expert Marketplace and inquire about booking her for your next event!